Weekly Legislative Update 2/23/13
Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coalition
Westword by Alan Prendergast
In an unusual court hearing unfolding in Castle Rock, attorneys for
Edward Montour Jr. are seeking to withdraw his guilty plea for the
murder of a correctional officer in 2002, claiming that he was mentally
ill at the time and seeking "court-assisted suicide" by firing his
lawyers in a death-penalty case.
"He was, in my opinion, a volunteer," former state chief deputy
public defender Sharlene Reynolds testified this morning. "He wanted to
be killed by the state."
The question of whether Montour was mentally competent to represent
himself is the latest hurdle in prosecutors' decade-long effort to
execute him -- and a critical test of new Eighteenth Judicial District
Attorney George Brauchler's pledge to pursue the death penalty, seldom used in Colorado, in cases of particularly heinous crimes.

The Denver Post
CAÑON CITY — Colorado's prison
population is aging quickly and more inmates than ever are sick with
illnesses that will kill them long before their sentences are up.
In
the first state prison hospice program in the nation, inmates of the
Colorado Territorial Correctional Facility in Cañon City are trained to
care for fellow prisoners as they follow the course of diseases such as
cancer, HIV/AIDS and hepatitis C toward the inevitable.
Colorado's
total prison population more than doubled from 1991 to 2009, but the
number of inmates age 50 or older increased 720 percent, according to
"Old Behind Bars," a 2012 study by Human Rights Watch. Nationwide, the
number of people in prison who are 65 or older increased 67 percent in
only three years to 26,200 in 2010.
"We're treating more guys,"
said Dave Tessier, a chiropractor who runs the Territorial infirmary and
hospice program. "It's only going to get worse."
In a prison
where executioners once administered a poison cocktail to condemned men,
nurses now feed morphine into the arms of the dying for their comfort.
Men convicted of brutal crimes minister to the physical needs of the ill
and elderly, and sometimes find redemption in the role of caretaker.
Colorado Independent
With a bill to repeal the death penalty
likely to be introduced in the 2013 Colorado Legislature, there are
bound to be philosophical arguments about the merits of capital
punishment. One thing that seems beyond debate, though, is that ending
the death penalty could save Colorado taxpayers a lot of money.
No one can say exactly how much Colorado spends administering its
death penalty, but it is certainly in the tens of millions of dollars
for each person executed. A study by the Death Penalty Information Center
in 2009 found that states with a death penalty spend an average of $10
million a year enforcing it. That same study said that 70 percent of the
expense stems from legal work that’s not necessary in non-capital
cases. Considering that Colorado executed one man in 1967 and one in
1997, the cost associated with killing almost no one quickly adds up.
“Since 1980, we [Colorado taxpayers] have spent tens of millions of
dollars on one execution,” said criminal defense attorney David Lane who
has represented many death-penalty eligible clients. “That’s money that
could go to schools. It could go to police officers.”
It
is with great sadness that we inform you of the passing of Dr. Rev.
Elaine Smith on Saturday, February 2, 2013. CCJRC and many others have
lost a long time friend, ally and champion. Elaine started a program
called Second Chance helping newly released inmates reintegrate back
into society and was also the director of Charities House Ministries, a
transitional housing program. She also spearheaded the Denver chapter
of All of Us or None, which brought together people who were involved in
the criminal justice system to fought against discrimination.
Her
infectious spirit and joyfulness will be sorely missed in the
community. We offer our deep condolences to her family and other loved
ones. Details about services are included below.
From the Denver Post.
Dr. Rev. Elaine Smith Obituary
(1951 - 2013)
61, Centennial. Wife of David M. Smith of Centennial; mother of
NeKesha (Bert) Bennett of Denver; and Niya Smith of Starkville, MS; 4
brothers, 1 sister and 10 grandchildren. A host of nieces, nephews,
cousins, other relatives and friends. Services Saturday, 10:00 a.m.,
Rising Star Missionary Baptist Church, 1500 S. Dayton St., to Hampden
Memorial Gardens. Visitation Friday, 4-6 p.m. and celebratory wake
service 6-8 p.m. both at Taylor Mortuary Denver Chapel, 2531 Ogden St.
PLEASE NOTE: Rev. Smith will lie in state on Saturday, 9-10 a.m. at the
church.
The Denver Post
Colorado's prison population is falling
so quickly that state officials are once again considering closing
prisons — a tough discussion given that prisons are often big employers
in the counties where they are located.
"It looks like the whole
system should be shrinking," said state Sen. Kent Lambert, R-Colorado
Springs, at a recent legislative hearing where Joint Budget Committee
members discussed the decline in inmates and a consultant's ongoing
study of which prisons should be closed or repurposed.
The study is due June 30.
In
December, there were 2,109 empty beds in prisons across Colorado. Most
were in private prisons, and the state is no longer paying for the
space.
Budget and criminal-justice statisticians predict the
number of unoccupied beds will rise to between 2,600 and 3,600 by June
2014.
Eliminating that much capacity could shut down two to 10 prisons, depending on the size of the facilities.
Colorado is already at 7,500 fewer inmates than it once expected in 2013 and has closed three state prisons.
"We think that is a really, really big deal," said Roxane White, chief
of staff to Gov. John Hickenlooper, referring to both the continuing
decline in prisoners and the prospect of saving money with further
prison closures.
The choice of which prisons to close is
complicated, state corrections officials and legislators say. The state
must still have a mix of minimum- to maximum-security facilities. Some
prisons are designed to use fewer guards, which reduces operating costs.
It's not generally easy for prison staff to move from one city to
another. Maintenance and energy use vary from prison to prison.
Colorado, for example, still operates two prisons that opened more than a
century ago.
"We are wrestling with what beds do we not need,"
Department of Corrections Director Tom Clements told a legislative
committee recently.
The decline in prisoners is good news for the
state, which saves tens of millions of dollars in the cost of housing
them. But closing prisons can be bad news for the small towns that rely
on them for jobs. Olney Springs in southeastern Colorado, for example,
has a population of less than 400. A private prison there has room for
1,700 inmates.
"Unfortunately, a lot of those smaller communities
were sold a bill of goods about (how) this is going to be good for your
community — and it did create an economic boom for them," said Douglas
Wilson, the state's chief public defender. "But now with the populations
going down, I think the legislature's going to have to make some tough
decisions about if they close, and if so, where do they close the
prisons."
Experts point to a mix of reasons for the decline in
prison population — including fewer prosecutions and changes in the way
the prison system is run.
The state's felony crime rate dropped by
a third from 2002 to 2011, Clements said. Possible reasons for that
include reductions in punishment for marijuana-related crimes,
successes of youth and gang-intervention programs, and an aging
population that has resulted in fewer young people getting in trouble.
In
addition, Clements, who became the state's corrections chief under
Hickenlooper, brought a very different attitude from his predecessors,
Wilson said. Parole and probation officers are giving second chances for
minor infringements, like a single failed drug test or failure to show
up for an appointment. Those offenders are not being sent back to
prison.
A new state law also allows prisoners to earn more time
off their sentences for good behavior, Clements said. Another new law
lowered the penalties for minor drug possession, Wilson said. There is
no longer a 24-year sentence for a parolee who walks away from his
registered address at a homeless shelter.
The savings to Colorado
taxpayers will vary significantly with the state's choices on what to
cut. Not sending an inmate to a private prison saves the state about
$20,000 a year. Closing the Fort Lyon prison in Las Animas saved nearly
$27,000 per inmate. Shutting down one wing at the Trinidad prison has
saved $5,800 per prisoner.
White told a health conference six
weeks ago in Denver that the governor hopes to move the prison savings
into health care, including better care in prisons. That might reduce
prison population further, as a third of Colorado's inmates have mental
illnesses.
SF Gate
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — After running for governor as a supporter of the death penalty, Gov. Mike Beebe
said Wednesday that the experience of signing a death warrant for the
first time caused his thinking on the issue to "evolve" and that he
would sign legislation outlawing the punishment if legislators were to
send him such a bill.
The
Democratic governor doesn't plan to make repealing the death penalty
part of his legislative agenda for this year's session, nor does he
intend to ask any lawmaker to introduce such legislation, Beebe's
spokesman, Matt DeCample, said. Several top lawmakers said it's unlikely
legislators would propose a death penalty repeal.
Beebe said he changed his mind about the death penalty after having to sign his first death warrant.
"The
awesome burden of being the last person to have to sign one of those
things sobers you differently than talking about it in the abstract,"
Beebe said.
His remarks came in response to an audience question during his appearance at the Political Animals Club meeting at the governor's mansion.
Since
taking office in 2007, Beebe has approved four executions, but none of
those have been carried out because of various court challenges.
In
signing the death warrants, Beebe said, he pored over "every word of
the testimony" in search of a "scintilla" of doubt about the conviction.
He said in all four cases, his review of the court papers convinced him
of the person's guilt but that the experience of having to sign the
order shifted his feelings about the death penalty.
Denver’s Martin Luther King Jr. Marade