Who is the Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coalition?

Our mission is to reverse the trend of mass incarceration in Colorado. We are a coalition of nearly 7,000 individual members and over 100 faith and community organizations who have united to stop perpetual prison expansion in Colorado through policy and sentence reform.

Our chief areas of interest include drug policy reform, women in prison, racial injustice, the impact of incarceration on children and families, the problems associated with re-entry and stopping the practice of using private prisons in our state.

If you would like to be involved please go to our website and become a member.


Wednesday, December 26, 2007

Tim Masters - One More Christmas in Prison

Tuesday marked the ninth Christmas Tim Masters has spent behind bars. If there's any upside, it's that he spent it at the Buena Vista Correctional Facility, where he has a television, a typewriter and other inmates to talk to. If he'd stayed at the Larimer County Detention Center, he would have had, at best, a book and a lonely 23-hour lockdown, just like every other day he spends there when he has a court appointment in Fort Collins. His family and his legal team hope it's the last Christmas he'll spend in a cell.

By this point in Masters' story, it's clear that nothing can be taken for granted. For his family, there have simply been too many disappointments, too many maddening delays and -- as any of his supporters will tell you -- too many acts of deception and misconduct by those who put him in prison in the first place. At no other point since he was arrested more than a decade ago have his supporters allowed themselves to feel as optimistic about his chances for vindication as they do now.

Last week, Masters and his family were once again crowded into courtroom 2-A in the Larimer County Courthouse. Although no one spoke of it, there was a palpable hope that he would be allowed to go home for Christmas. Every hushed conversation between legal teams took on new significance for Masters' aunts, uncles and cousins. "Yesterday, it was pretty high," said Betty Schneider, one of Masters' aunts, describing her optimism, especially when all the lawyers left the courtroom to confer in the hallway. "I thought maybe when they went out, that they're getting together and would say they would let him out until we have a new trial. I kind of hoped that's what they were doing, but we found out that it was something else."

Such disappointments are practically mundane by now. Masters had been labeled a killer since Feb. 11, 1987, the day he found a woman's dead body in a field behind his house but failed to report it to police. He was 15 years old and said he thought it was fake. He maintained his innocence the next day in a nine-hour police interrogation. He maintained it in 1992 when he was again questioned by detectives for two days. He maintained it when he was arrested in 1998, and when he stood trial in 1999. He maintained his innocence through two failed appeals after his conviction, and he maintains it today.

It hasn't done any good. Masters' effort to win a new trial has dragged through court since May 2003 and over the summer, Schneider and other family members said that they'd long ago learned the protective benefits of pessimism when it came to considering Masters' future. As Tim's uncle, John Masters, put it at the time, "I feel like I've been kicked in the stomach by this judicial system. I don't want to get knocked on my butt again."

In the last six months, his former lawyers have gone so far as to flatly say he was framed for murder and that some of the most well-respected names in local law enforcement intentionally withheld, destroyed or manipulated evidence so that Masters would spend his life in prison.

Even the special prosecutors assigned to the case agree that Masters' defense has made valid points, at least to a degree. At the end of testimony last week, prosecutor Michael Goodbee told Judge Joseph Weatherby that he is prepared to agree with the defense -- likely as soon as this week -- that some violations of discovery rules have taken place.

Although Masters wasn't let out of prison for Christmas, Goodbee's announcement was a welcome gift.

"We're very optimistic now," Schneider said later. "We feel there's a very good chance he'll get a new trial."

As the hearings went into recess for the remainder of the year, the case stood at a pivotal -- and frustrating -- point. Masters' new defense attorneys, David Wymore and Maria Liu, rested their case after months of testimony. They introduced reams of documents and other evidence that they said was intentionally withheld from Masters' lawyers during the 1999 trial, information they said could have been used to establish reasonable doubt in the minds of jurors. Their case was strong enough on certain points that Goodbee conceded two of them on cross examination last week. Questioning Erik Fischer, Masters' former lead attorney, he agreed that the defense should have been given hundreds of pages of so-called "extractions," or supporting opinions and documents, that supplemented a report from the state's expert witness. He also said Fischer should have been given a transcript of a tape-recorded conversation between Masters and his father during a break in his interrogation on Feb. 12, 1987.

Goodbee didn't elaborate on what his stipulations of discovery violations would be. If so, it's a partial concession. Wymore hoped to expedite the case by blocking the testimony of the prosecution's witnesses, most notably those of county judges Terry Gilmore and Jolene Blair, by arguing that whatever they have to say is irrelevant. He was unsuccessful.

Gilmore and Blair prosecuted Masters in 1999 when they worked for the Larimer District Attorney's Office. Along with police Lt. Jim Broderick, who built the case against Masters when he was a detective, they have been accused of hiding evidence.

Both of Masters' former lawyers testified that all of the information that wasn't disclosed to them was not only relevant and exculpatory to their client, but mandated for disclosure by federal and state law.

With the ball in the prosecution's court, it's still not clear if the judges will testify, or what strategy they will use to counter Wymore's case. Goodbee can argue that the disputed material wasn't subject to disclosure, or that the defense did in fact receive information they said they hadn't.

The case's continuance into 2008 popped the balloon of optimism Masters' family had been floating, although they knew it was unrealistic to expect the prosecutors to stipulate to Wymore's entire case and move for Masters to be released in time for Christmas pending a new trial.

It may have been another letdown, but they were bolstered by their belief that by this time next year he will not be in prison, but at home.

"We are just real sure on that, that this is going to be the last time," Schneider said. "He's had enough Christmases behind bars."

The background

Tim Masters was convicted in 1999 of murdering and mutilating Peggy Hettrick in 1987, when he was 15 years old. The conviction was upheld as far as the state Supreme Court, but Masters has been in hearings since 2005 trying to get a new trial. He argues that prosecutors and police withheld information from his defense lawyers that would have resulted in an acquittal.

Prosecutors from the Adams County District Attorney's Office are representing the state since the entire Eighth Judicial District has been removed from the case due to conflict of interest.
Greeley Tribune

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Sounds like this case takes on alot of things from bad police all the way up to a supreme court. How could so many wrong judgements and nistakes have been made? And all without any evidence. natzees never die they just move onto other countries and use better cover. I better watch what I write I might be next on their list of people they might take to kindly to.sometimes cops just take things too personnal and are always too egotistical to be able to do things right and with immunity it is so easy to get that way.

Anonymous said...

 “胡一刀,曲池喝花酒,天樞!苗人鳳酒店喝酒 ,地倉,合谷!個嘶啞的嗓子低沉地叫暑假打工 著。叫聲中充滿著怨毒寒假打工 和憤怒,語聲從酒店小姐 牙齒縫中迸出來,似是酒店兼職 千年万年、永恒的咒禮服店 ,每一個字音上涂著血和仇恨。 突突突突四酒店經紀 聲響,四道金光酒店兼差,四枝金鏢連珠發出,射向兩塊木牌。木牌的酒店 正面反面都繪著一個全身人酒店經紀人 形,一塊上繪的是個濃髯粗豪的大漢,旁注“胡一刀”三字;另一塊上繪的是個瘦長漢子,旁注“苗人鳳”三字,人形上書明人体周身穴酒店現領。木牌下面接有一柄,兩個身手矯捷的壯漢各持一牌,在練武廳中滿廳游走東北角一張椅子中坐著酒店經紀爆米花個五十來歲的白發婆婆,口中喊著胡一刀或苗人鳳穴道的名稱。一個二十來歲的英俊少年勁裝結束,鏢囊中酒店經紀帶著十几枝金鏢,听得那婆婆喊出穴道名稱,右手打工揚,就是一道金光射出,釘向木牌。兩個持牌壯漢頭戴鋼絲罩子兼差上身穿了厚棉襖再罩牛皮背心,唯恐少年失了准頭,金鏢招呼到他們身上。兩人竄高伏低,酒店打工擺木牌,要讓他酒店上班不易打中。 大廳外的窗口,伏著一個少女假日打工一個青年漢子。兩人在窗紙上挖破了兩個小孔,各用台北酒店經紀右眼湊著向里偷窺。兩人見那少年身手不凡,發鏢甚准,不由酒店pt 互相對望了一眼,臉上酒店pt都露出訝异的神色。
  天空黑沉酒店應酬 沉的堆滿了烏云。大雨傾盆而下,夾著一陣陣的電閃雷轟,勢道嚇人粉味。黃豆大的雨點打在地下,直濺到窗外兩酒店經紀PRETTY GIRL少年男女酒店經濟 的身上。 們都身披油布雨衣,對廳上的事很感好奇酒店經濟再湊眼到窗洞上去看時,只听得那婆婆打工兼差道:“准頭還可將就,就是沒勁儿,今日就練到這里。”說著慢慢禮服店站起身來。